The worst hour of my day is not the morning walk. It is three in the afternoon, when the porch is too hot to sit on, the late walk is still two hours away, and every dog in the house has run out of things to do.
I look after other people's dogs in my home in Tehachapi, California, and I have done it for nine years. Usually there are two or three here at a time, plus Pepper, my own cattle dog mix. She is six, she is forty-two pounds, and she gets bored faster than any dog I have met. A bored dog does not lie down in my experience. A bored dog finds a job, and the job is usually my baseboards or somebody else's bedding.
The West Paw Toppl is what I hand out at that hour. It is a fillable treat toy made in the USA from a material the company calls Zogoflex, and it is the most useful thing in my kitchen drawer. Not because it is clever. Because it works, it survives my house, and I can wash it without a bottle brush.
The toy I reach for when the afternoon needs to go quiet
I keep two in rotation and one is nearly always in the freezer. If your dog is the kind that finds a job when nobody gives him one, start here.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →I have ten reasons and they are all things I noticed in my own kitchen rather than things I read on a label. Here they are, in the order I would tell a friend over the fence.
Frozen, one toy buys you 25 quiet minutes on a hot afternoon
This is the main event. I pack both toys with kibble and plain yogurt, press it down with a spoon, and put them in the freezer overnight. The next afternoon one comes out solid as a brick. Pepper carries it to the covered porch and works at it for about twenty-five minutes, and she does not stop because she is full. She stops because the work is done. That is a different kind of tired than a walk gives you, and it is exactly the kind I want at three o'clock.
Filling it takes seconds, so it actually gets filled
A toy that is a nuisance to prepare stops getting prepared. That is what the graveyard on my hall closet shelf is made of. This one takes a scoop of kibble and a spoon of yogurt and it is done, and I fill two while the kettle boils. Some days I skip the freezer entirely and just load dry kibble. That still buys ten minutes of nosing it around the kitchen floor, which is ten minutes more than an empty bowl ever bought me.
It goes in the top rack of the dishwasher and comes out clean
This matters more to me than anything printed on the packaging. Every Sunday both toys go in the top rack with the mugs and they come out with nothing left in the corners. No scrubbing, no soaking, no smell. Old yogurt is the exact thing that turns a filled toy unpleasant to handle by Friday, and the dishwasher solves it without me thinking about it. The listing says top rack safe and that has been true here every week for a year.
It slows down a dog that eats like a vacuum cleaner
A young lab who stays with me a week at a time used to be finished with his bowl before I had straightened up from setting it down. Now his kibble goes into a toy and he takes ten minutes over it. The product listing says it helps slow fast eaters, and I can tell you what that looks like in a real kitchen. Less gulping. Less pacing afterward. A dog who settles on the rug instead of standing by the counter asking me for something else.
Pepper has not put a mark in it in a year of hard chewing
Pepper is a serious chewer. She has taken the corners off things I would have bet money on. This toy has been in the house a year and I cannot find a puncture in it. West Paw sells it as guaranteed tough, and for once the label and my floor agree. I will not tell you it is indestructible, because no toy is, and I still pick it up when I leave the room. But it has held, and it has held with the dog who ruins nearly everything else.
Two of them means one is always ready to go
The system is simple. One is in the freezer, one is drying in the rack. I own two and I have never once wished for a third. If you have two dogs, buy four and give each dog its own in its own spot, because a toy this good is worth guarding and I do not allow guarding in my house. One dog, one toy, separate corners of the porch.
The small size is right for guest dogs and snug for mine
I own the small, and it suits a beagle or a spaniel staying the week down to the ground. Pepper at forty-two pounds can use it, but it is snug for her, so she only gets it with me sitting out there. If your dog is bigger than mine, go up a size rather than making the small work. That is the honest version, and I would rather you hear it from me than find it out on a hot Tuesday.
It gives a bored dog a job at the hour trouble starts
Three in the afternoon is when the pacing starts here. This is the answer that does not involve putting my shoes back on. Fifteen minutes of nosing and licking and the room goes quiet. I have handed a filled one to a nervous guest on his first evening and watched him stop patrolling the hallway. I am not going to tell you it fixes a nervous dog, because it does not. It gives a dog something to do, and something to do is most of the battle.
Plain yogurt and canned pumpkin wipe in and freeze solid
I keep the fillings boring because boring is safe. Plain yogurt, canned pumpkin, kibble, and peanut butter with no xylitol in it. Nothing else goes in. A thin smear frozen flat gives twenty minutes to a dog that licks slowly. The toy is unscented, so my freezer does not smell of it, and it is non-toxic and BPA-free, which matters to me because Pepper has her tongue on it for half an hour at a stretch.
Just over four ounces, so the dog carries it to her own spot
Pepper picks it up, carries it to the porch, and drops it where she wants it. She has her spot, I have my chair, and the toy does the rest. When she is finished she leaves it by the door and it goes in the sink. That is the entire routine and it has not changed in a year. The West Paw Toppl is the one thing in that drawer I would buy again tomorrow.
Two toys, one always in the freezer, and the loudest hour of my day went quiet.
What I'd Skip
I would skip the KONG Classic for this particular job, and I say that as someone who kept them in the house for three years for guest dogs. The opening is narrow, which makes it slow to fill and slower to clean, and the last one left my house the month this toy arrived. I would also skip the flimsy rubber toys that turn up in bargain bins, because Pepper has opened most of them in an afternoon and I have thrown the pieces away.
And if your dog is Pepper's size or bigger, skip the small and go up. The small is a guest dog size in this house, not a main dog size. The other thing I would skip is leaving any dog alone with a filled toy. Nothing I have written here replaces a walk. Pepper still gets both of hers, and this is a twenty-five minute patch in the middle of the day, not a substitute for exercise or training.
One frozen toy, one quiet afternoon
Two in rotation, the freezer doing the work, and a dog who has something to do besides redecorate. That is the whole pitch.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →